Sen. John Fetterman’s (D-Pa.) openness to President-elect Trump has sparked questions and frustrations among Democrats.
After Trump’s win, Fetterman criticized his party’s messaging and showed interest in some of Trump’s policy ideas.
Trump himself praised Fetterman after their meeting last week. Fetterman, already divisive for supporting Israel, is drawing more attention as some speculate about his ambitions.
“I wouldn’t 100 percent rule out that maybe or slightly there is some thinking about different or future opportunities,” said Democratic strategist Eddie Vale.
Others are unsure of Fetterman’s motives. “There’s no telling with any certainty what Fetterman’s motivations are,” said progressive strategist Norman Solomon. “But clearly, he has been moving rightward.”
Less than a week before inauguration, Fetterman’s meeting with Trump at Mar-a-Lago is stirring speculation. Trump called Fetterman “a fascinating man,” contrasting him with other Democrats.
Republican strategist Ford O’Connell sees strategy in Trump’s outreach. “If you’re willing to put the country first, I’m willing to work with you,” he said.
The two populist leaders discussed shared priorities, including Israel, border security, and steel manufacturing, according to Trump’s team.
Fetterman’s willingness to engage is notable. Representing a politically diverse state, he built a coalition of working-class voters in his 2022 Senate campaign.
Some Democrats saw his victory as a blueprint for winning back non-college-educated voters. He distanced himself from the “progressive” label, gaining broader appeal. Trump recognized this, calling Fetterman “commonsense.”
Despite rejecting the progressive tag, Fetterman supported left-leaning policies, earning Bernie Sanders’ endorsement. Progressives hoped he would champion union jobs and wage increases in the Senate.
But his recent actions confuse some Democrats. During his campaign against Mehmet Oz, Fetterman vowed not to be like Sen. Joe Manchin. Now, some see him moving in that direction.
To others, Fetterman’s adaptability isn’t surprising. “He ran as a younger, taller, tatted Bernie bro,” said GOP consultant Christopher Nicholas, noting his knack for shocking and deflecting criticism.
Fetterman’s unclear ambitions make him intriguing. He’s seen as a potential ally for Trump on key nominations, including Robert F. Kennedy Jr.’s for Health and Human Services.
Fetterman’s health history may influence his decisions, but some argue his motives are straightforward. “He is a senator from a 50/50 state,” Vale said. “He’s trying to have a foot in both worlds.”